✨ New Arrivals Just Dropped!Explore

Home Shop Cart Account

Ice Cream Pies

Ice Cream Pies

Price

Min

-

Max

Collections

Call For PriceCustom OrdersallBakery Menu - Order Online!Baby Shower CakesChildren's Birthday CakesBridal Shower CakesBaby Shower Cakes in Somerville NJCustom Cupcakes/Cake JarsCorporate Gifting & CateringGourmet CupcakesChristmas Dessert Menu 2024Decadent Brownies & Dessert BarsChristmas Dessert Menu Order Online Somerville NJCheesecakes, Crumb Cakes, Tres LechesDecorated Sugar CookiesCustom Cookies, Macarons, and CakesiclesBaked Goods - Call For PriceFrench Macarons MenuBack To School Cookies

Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive offers, new arrivals, and style inspiration.

Shop

All Products
New Arrivals
Sale

Company

Shipping Info
FAQ
Contact Us

About

About Us
Returns
Privacy

© 2026 Blue Sheep Bake Shop. All rights reserved.

Ice Cream Pies | Blue Sheep Bake Shop

NEW

Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pie

$34.95

NEW

Reese's Peanut Butter Ice Cream Pie

$39.95

NEW

Death By Chocolate Ice Cream Pie

$34.95

-65%NEW

Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Pie

$34.95

$12.23

-65%NEW

Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie

$34.95

$12.23

-65%NEW

Oreo Ice Cream Pie

$34.95

$12.23